Godly Sorrow vs. Worldly Sorrow: How to Tell the Difference in the Wake of Betrayal
By Tesa Saulmon, LMHC, CSAT
Root to Bloom Therapy | Faith-Integrated, Trauma-Informed Therapy for Healing from Betrayal and Addiction
When a marriage experiences betrayal—through infidelity, sexual sin, or secret-keeping—remorse often enters the room. But not all sorrow is created equal.
Some tears are rooted in humility.
Others are rooted in self-protection.
Some confessions are the fruit of conviction.
Others are the result of consequences catching up.
And Scripture makes a bold distinction between the two:
“Godly sorrow brings repentance that leads to salvation and leaves no regret, but worldly sorrow brings death.”
—2 Corinthians 7:10 (NIV)
So what exactly is the difference between godly sorrow and worldly sorrow—and why does it matter for healing, especially after betrayal?
1. What Is Godly Sorrow?
Godly sorrow is grief that flows from a heart broken over sin—not just its consequences, but its very nature. It’s the awareness that what you did not only hurt your spouse, but grieved the heart of God.
It’s not focused on image management, getting out of trouble, or silencing your wife’s pain. It’s focused on repentance. On heart transformation. On walking in the light, no matter how painful the truth is.
Godly sorrow says:
“I can’t believe I did that to you.”
“I see how deeply I’ve hurt you—and I won’t defend it.”
“I’m broken over who I became in this process.”
“This isn’t about whether you forgive me. It’s about who I want to become.”
Godly sorrow leads to a turning. A changing of course. A soul shift. It doesn't just feel bad—it leads to doing different.
2. What Is Worldly Sorrow?
Worldly sorrow is grief over being caught, losing comfort, or facing consequences. It may include tears, shame, and big emotional displays—but it lacks repentance. It’s performative. Self-centered. Defensive. Temporary.
It wants relief, not restoration.
It wants the relationship to “get back to normal,” without doing the slow and holy work of change.
Worldly sorrow says:
“I hate that you’re so upset with me.”
“I already said I was sorry—how long will you punish me?”
“I hate how this makes me look.”
“I feel awful. Isn’t that enough?”
At its root, worldly sorrow is still about me.
Godly sorrow is about you and God and truth.
3. Why This Matters in Betrayal Recovery
For the betrayed spouse, it is crucial to discern whether your husband’s remorse is godly or worldly. Because it affects your safety. Your trust. Your discernment moving forward.
Godly sorrow is the soil that trust can be replanted in—over time.
Worldly sorrow creates a cycle where you are continually re-injured by empty words and unchanged behavior.
Here’s how this can look in real life:
Godly SorrowWorldly SorrowSeeks accountability voluntarilyAvoids responsibility unless forcedTells the whole truthMinimizes, lies by omission, trickle-truthsPursues healing for both of youJust wants the pain to stop quicklyOwns the impact on you, not just the sin itselfMakes it about his feelings or shameAccepts that trust takes time to rebuildFeels entitled to your forgiveness and trustGrieves the sin against GodFears the fallout or consequences most
4. The Fruit Will Tell You Everything
Jesus said, “You will know them by their fruits.” (Matthew 7:16)
The fruit of godly sorrow is a repentant life:
Humility
Consistency
Accountability
Emotional availability
A desire for truth over comfort
A willingness to sit in discomfort for the sake of someone else’s healing
The fruit of worldly sorrow is a self-serving cycle:
Defensiveness
Blame-shifting
“Apology fatigue”
Impatience with your grief
Passive or performative engagement in healing
Outbursts, shutdowns, or avoidance when confronted with your pain
5. What If You’re the One Who Betrayed? How Do You Know Which Sorrow You’re Living In?
Take a deep breath. God’s grace is not just for the betrayed. It’s for the betrayer too.
But His grace doesn’t excuse sin. It transforms sinners.
Ask yourself:
Do I feel broken because I broke her, or because I got caught?
Am I more focused on her forgiveness or on becoming someone worth trusting again?
Am I trying to avoid consequences—or embrace the deep work that leads to true change?
If you’re unsure—bring it to God. He’s not looking for performance. He’s looking for surrender.
“Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me.”
—Psalm 51:10
David wrote those words after committing adultery and orchestrating a murder. His life was stained with shame—but he returned to God with godly sorrow.
And that’s where redemption begins.
6. A Word of Hope for Couples Walking Through This
Whether you’re the one who was betrayed or the one who betrayed, you need to know this:
God is not asking for perfection. He’s inviting repentance.
And repentance is not just a one-time event—it’s a way of life.
If you’re a wife navigating the confusion of your husband’s apologies, you’re allowed to wait and watch for fruit. That’s not bitterness—it’s wisdom.
If you’re a husband trying to figure out how to make things right, stop trying to be perfect. Just be real. Be humble. Be broken before God. And let that brokenness lead you to change—not just tears.
Healing begins when sorrow leads to repentance.
And repentance always leads to life.
If you’re looking for guidance through this process, Root to Bloom Therapy offers a safe, faith-integrated space for healing, truth-telling, and rebuilding. You don’t have to walk through this alone.
📍 In-person therapy in Pensacola and Jacksonville, Florida
🌐 Telehealth therapy throughout the state of Florida
📞 850-530-7236
🔗 www.roottobloomtherapy.com
📲 Instagram: @talkingwithtesa
📘 Facebook: Tesa Saulmon
📺 YouTube: @talkingwithtesa
Remember: Godly sorrow doesn’t just grieve the sin. It leads you home.
